RULEBOOK Arbitration Standards & Table Governance Inquiries: [email protected]
Arbitration Protocols & Disputes

Rulings Before the Final Answer

Disputes are inevitable when points and pride are at stake. Having unambiguous, pre-published rules prevents shouting matches and keeps the room focused on fair play.

The 10 Standard Desk Rulings

Official Guidance
1. How should hosts handle minor spelling errors on written answer sheets?

The standard phonetic tolerance applies: if the written answer is phonetically unambiguous and cannot be confused with another entity, award full points. For instance, writing "Gorbachov" instead of "Gorbachev" is acceptable. However, writing "Austria" instead of "Australia" is not a spelling error; it is a wrong answer and receives zero points.

2. Is a surname alone sufficient for historical or cultural figures?

Unless the host specifically announced "Full name required" before reading the question, a correct surname is always sufficient (e.g., "Churchill", "Hemingway", "Picasso"). The only exception is when multiple prominent figures share a surname in the same field (e.g., Roosevelts, Pitts, or Brontë sisters), in which case the forename is mandatory.

3. What happens if a question contains a factual error in its own premise?

If a question contains a fundamentally flawed premise (e.g., referring to an event happening in the wrong decade or misattributing a book), the host must void the question entirely and award zero points to all tables, or read an immediate reserve question. Never award points selectively based on what the question "meant" to say.

4. What is the maximum fair team size for pub competitions?

The standard adult maximum is six players per table. Tables competing with seven or eight players should either split into two independent teams or incur a mandatory 2-point per extra player handicap per round to preserve competitive balance for smaller groups.

5. How should a tie be broken if the estimation question yields an exact draw?

In the rare event that two teams guess identical distances from the actual number in a tie-breaker, the team whose guess did not exceed the true figure wins. If both are on the same side and equidistant, conduct a second sudden-death question from the sealed reserve list.

6. Are abbreviations accepted for country names and institutions?

Universally recognized acronyms and abbreviations (e.g., USA, UK, USSR, NASA, FBI, NATO) are fully accepted. Obscure local abbreviations or colloquial nicknames are unacceptable unless approved by the host before marking begins.

7. What is the procedure if a peer-marking table deliberately underscores a rival?

All tables have the right to a brief audit of their sheet after marks are announced. If a table believes their paper was unfairly graded by a peer marker, the captain brings the paper directly to the host's desk. If deliberate wrongful marking is proven, the offending table receives a 5-point sportsmanship penalty.

8. How should mobile phone disputes be arbitrated without causing a scene?

Do not publicly accuse individuals over the microphone. The host should approach the table quietly between rounds and say: "We have had a query regarding screens at this table; please keep all phones stacked face-down in the center glass so nobody can question your team's integrity." This diffuses suspicion without creating an adversarial atmosphere.

9. What is the policy regarding decimal answers or unit conversions?

If a question asks for a measurement, specify the unit in the question (e.g., "in kilometers" or "in kilograms"). If a player provides the mathematically correct equivalent in miles or pounds, award full points if the conversion is accurate within 2%.

10. Can a host's ruling be overturned once the final scores are announced?

Once the host completes the podium awards and signs off the fixture, all rulings are permanent. Post-game discussions are welcome at the desk for clarifying future fixtures, but historical prize distributions remain final to prevent endless post-match litigation.